Compare what the same annual contribution could grow to via a SIP versus PPF.
SIP maturity: Standard SIP future-value formula
PPF maturity: Standard PPF annual compounding formula
A SIP vs PPF calculator compares two of India's most popular long-term savings routes. The same monthly amount goes into an equity SIP at your expected return, and, as a yearly total, into a Public Provident Fund account at the PPF rate. The calculator shows both maturity values and the difference.
PPF is backed by the Government of India, has a 15-year lock-in and a yearly deposit cap of ₹1.5 lakh, and its interest and maturity amount are tax-free. A SIP has no cap and can be redeemed any time, but its returns are market-linked and taxable. People comparing the two are usually deciding where their Section 80C or retirement savings should go.
1. Fix the monthly amount P, the period N years, the expected SIP return Rs% and the PPF rate Rp%.
2. SIP side: with i = Rs ÷ 1200 and n = 12N, FV = P × [((1 + i)ⁿ − 1) ÷ i] × (1 + i).
3. PPF side: take the yearly contribution A = 12P and run it for the smaller of N and 15 years.
4. For each PPF year: balance = (balance + A) × (1 + Rp ÷ 100). This assumes the whole year's deposit is made at the start of the year.
5. Difference = SIP maturity − PPF maturity.
6. Remember that the PPF figure is tax-free while the SIP figure is before capital gains tax.
PPF interest is calculated on the lowest balance in the account between the 5th and the last day of each month, and it is credited once a year at the end of the financial year. This is why many depositors put the full year's amount in before the 5th of April: it then earns interest for all twelve months. The calculator models exactly that best case, with one deposit at the start of each year compounded annually. If you deposit monthly instead, your actual PPF maturity will be somewhat lower than shown.
A PPF account matures after 15 financial years. It can be extended in blocks of five years, with or without fresh deposits, but that is a separate choice. So if you enter a period longer than 15 years, the calculator still runs PPF for only 15 years while the SIP runs for the full period. In that case the difference includes the SIP's extra years of contributions and growth, not just the rate gap. For a clean rate comparison, keep the period at 15 years.
PPF falls under the exempt-exempt-exempt treatment: the deposit can qualify for a deduction under the old tax regime, and the interest and maturity are tax-free. A SIP's gains are taxed at redemption. So a 7.1% PPF rate should be compared with the SIP's post-tax return, not its headline return. The PPF rate is set by the government every quarter and can change during your 15 years, while the SIP return is only an assumption. The comparison is really between certainty with a cap and a lock-in, and higher expected growth with risk.
Arjun wants to put ₹12,500 a month, which is ₹1.5 lakh a year, towards a 15-year goal and is weighing PPF at 7.1% against a SIP he expects to earn 11%.
Answer: SIP maturity value ₹57,35,720; PPF maturity value ₹40,68,209; Difference ₹16,67,510
Entering a monthly amount above ₹12,500; PPF deposits above ₹1.5 lakh a year are not allowed, but the calculator does not cap them.
Choosing a period above 15 years and reading the difference as a pure return gap.
Comparing the tax-free PPF figure with the pre-tax SIP figure.
Depositing into PPF after the 5th of the month and expecting the calculator's figure.
Ignoring PPF's lock-in when the money may be needed before 15 years.
Deciding how to split yearly tax-saving money between PPF and ELSS or other equity funds.
Planning a child's higher education with a mix of guaranteed and market-linked savings.
Showing a conservative investor what the safety of PPF costs in expected returns.
Building the debt part of a long-term portfolio.
Why is PPF capped at 15 years in this comparison?
PPF has a fixed 15-year tenure by design (extendable afterward in blocks), so if you choose a longer comparison period, the PPF side of the calculation still reflects only what its standard term would actually produce.